Wisconsin sheriff sues woman in case he calls an “ICE detention hoax,” citing hotel records, messages and video
Dodge County Sheriff Dale Schmidt filed a federal lawsuit against Sundas “Sunny” Naqvi, alleging she fabricated claims of a 40‑hour ICE detention; his office says hotel folios, WhatsApp messages, CBP records and surveillance video undercut her account.
- Investigation found documentary evidence — hotel folios, CBP logs, messages and video that investigators say contradict Naqvi’s timeline.
- Allegations drew political amplification — statements by elected officials that the sheriff’s complaint disputes and includes in the suit.
- Civil suit filed; criminal outcome uncertain — evidence shared with federal and state partners while the probe remains active.
Key information
- Plaintiff: Dodge County Sheriff Dale Schmidt filed a federal complaint after a weeks‑long probe into claims by Sundas “Sunny” Naqvi. Fox News
- Allegations: Naqvi said she was seized at O’Hare Airport, transferred to Illinois and Wisconsin detention centers and held roughly 40 hours, including at the Dodge County Jail. Fox News
- Investigative findings: CBP records, hotel folios, WhatsApp messages and surveillance video reportedly place Naqvi at a Rosemont hotel, not in custody. Fox News
- Political amplification: Cook County Commissioner Kevin Morrison repeated and expanded the detention claim; the sheriff’s lawsuit disputes those statements. Fox News
- Status: Findings were shared with partners including the FBI and Illinois State Police; the investigation is active and criminal charges are not certain. Fox News
What investigators say they found
Sheriff Schmidt says his office “ran down every lead” and reviewed records from multiple agencies. According to the complaint and the sheriff’s public statements, U.S. Customs and Border Protection records show Naqvi entered secondary inspection at O’Hare Airport at about 10:46 a.m. on March 5 and was released about an hour later at 11:42 a.m.
Investigators say there is no CBP record showing any subsequent detention or transfer of Naqvi after her release from secondary inspection. Fox News
Hotel records and surveillance
Records cited in the complaint show Naqvi checked into a Hampton Inn & Suites in Rosemont at 1:17 p.m. on March 5, just over an hour after her reported CBP release. Hotel folio pages listed room charges and purchases between March 5 and March 8 — the same period she later said she was held by immigration authorities.
Sheriff’s investigators say surveillance video and other documentation do not place her in any Dodge County facility during that time. Fox News
Texts and messages
The complaint references WhatsApp messages sent from Naqvi on days she claimed to be in custody. Investigators say those messages show normal conversations about food, work and daily plans — including requests to use a card to order food — and at least one message referencing spa services, which Sheriff Schmidt notes are not available at the Broadview facility in Chicago or at the Dodge County Jail.
Sheriff Schmidt highlighted these messages to question the veracity of Naqvi’s account. Fox News
The sheriff’s assessment
“Not physically possible,” Sheriff Schmidt said of the assembled timeline, arguing the complaint was filed to set the public record straight after widespread attention without verified evidence.
The complaint contends the dissemination of Naqvi’s allegations harmed the reputation of Dodge County law enforcement and misled the public. Fox News
Political amplification and public response
The case gained rapid attention after social posts compared the claims to the Jussie Smollett incident and circulated widely. The X account Libs of Chicago posted that Skokie “has themselves their very own Jussie Smollett,” and other users made similar comparisons, fueling media and political interest. Fox News
Cook County Commissioner Kevin Morrison publicly repeated and expanded Naqvi’s account, alleging she and five others were transported across state lines and accusing local authorities of a cover‑up. The sheriff’s lawsuit disputes those assertions and includes Morrison’s statements. Fox News
Prior incidents and credibility questions
The Dodge County complaint references earlier investigations involving Naqvi that produced unsubstantiated findings, including an alleged sexual assault that authorities later determined to be false, according to the sheriff’s office. These past matters are cited to question credibility as the current case proceeds. Fox News
Legal steps and possible outcomes
Schmidt’s filing is a civil suit in federal court intended to address reputational and public‑harm claims tied to the episode. The sheriff’s office says it shared evidence with federal and state partners — including the FBI and Illinois State Police — for further review. Prosecutors cautioned that pursuing criminal charges may be difficult but did not rule out the possibility if actionable violations are found. Fox News
Department of Homeland Security stance
The Department of Homeland Security previously told the public that Naqvi’s claims were false. That DHS statement, along with CBP records cited by the sheriff, form part of the official record used to challenge the detention allegation. Fox News
Reporting standards and public trust
Sheriff Schmidt said his office launched the inquiry after allegations gained wide attention despite what he described as a lack of verified evidence. The goal, he said, was to separate fact from fiction and protect the integrity of local law enforcement. The suit and the public briefing reflect a push to hold accountable those who make claims that draw national attention and could harm institutions or individuals without proof. Fox News
Implications for the United States
- Trust in agencies and the rule of law: High‑profile allegations, if unverified, can erode public trust and complicate cooperation between communities and agencies. Fox News
- Political weaponization: The episode underscores how immigration claims can be amplified as political tools, raising questions about responsibility when officials repeat unverified allegations. Fox News
- Resource allocation: Investigating widely publicized but unverified claims consumes time and money from local and federal agencies, potentially prompting calls for clearer standards before public officials amplify serious accusations. Fox News
- Impact on immigration debate: False claims can distort public debate; officials and advocates must balance protecting due process with preventing misinformation. Fox News
- Legal precedent and accountability: The civil suit could influence how officials respond to public allegations about enforcement and whether reputational claims tied to false public allegations can proceed in court. Fox News
Reporting note
This article is based on the sheriff’s complaint and public accounts of the investigation, as reported by local and national outlets. Key details cited here come from reporting that includes statements by Dodge County Sheriff Dale Schmidt and documents presented during the inquiry. Source material: Fox News
