Skip to content

ExplainerHealthCalifornia3 min read

Why a brain tumor found on a preventive scan is putting full-body MRIs back in the spotlight

Despite interest in full-body MRI screening, federal regulators and medical groups warn the scans can cause more harm than good for healthy people.

Share

Topics

MRI scanner in a medical room with a patient table ready for imaging.

REDWOOD CITY, Calif., July 21 (San Francisco News Online) — A preventive scan that found a brain tumor has renewed interest in full-body MRI screening. For people thinking about whether to buy one of these scans, the bigger question is not whether an MRI can ever find something serious. It can. The question is whether routine whole-body screening helps healthy people more than it harms them.

Federal regulators and major medical groups say the answer is still no for most people without symptoms or a specific risk.

What is a full-body MRI?

A full-body MRI is a scan that images much of the body in one sitting. Unlike CT scans, MRI does not use ionizing radiation, the American Cancer Society says.

Companies that sell the scans often market them as a way to spot cancer and other diseases early. Prenuvo, one of the best-known providers, says its scan can detect more than 500 conditions, including some cancers at an early stage.

Why doctors are cautious

The Food and Drug Administration says it knows of no scientific evidence that whole-body scanning of people without symptoms provides more benefit than harm.

The American College of Radiology said in an April 2023 statement that there is not enough evidence to recommend total-body screening for patients who have no symptoms, no risk factors and no family history suggesting disease or serious injury.

The American College of Preventive Medicine says doctors should not use whole-body scans for early tumor detection in people without symptoms of illness.

A JAMA editorial by Matthew Davenport, a University of Michigan radiologist, and Dr. Scott Reeder said no major medical group recommends whole-body MRI for the general population because the benefits have not been proven.

The concern is not just missed cancer. It is also what happens when a scan finds something unclear.

What can go wrong?

The American Cancer Society says full-body MRI screening can lead to false positives, incidental findings, anxiety and unnecessary follow-up tests or procedures. Those extra tests can include more imaging, biopsies or specialist visits.

Dr. Rebecca Smith-Bindman, a UCSF radiology outcomes researcher, told CBS San Francisco there is “not a stitch of evidence” that the scan helps people live longer or better. She also warned that there could be “tremendous numbers of false positives.”

Davenport told ABC News that the harms come from “invasive testing or surgeries or follow-up of findings that are of uncertain benefit.”

There is another risk too: false reassurance. The Cleveland Clinic says a full-body MRI can miss problems, so a normal scan does not mean a person has no disease.

Who might benefit?

Doctors do use MRI screening in some situations, but those are usually targeted cases, not blanket screening for everyone. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force, for example, gives pancreatic cancer screening in asymptomatic adults who are not known to be at high risk a D rating, meaning the harms outweigh the benefits.

That is one reason experts say broad screening is different from focused testing for a person with symptoms, a strong family history or a known genetic risk.

What about cost?

The American Cancer Society says insurance companies rarely pay for full-body MRI because it is not part of standard medical care. That means many people would have to pay out of pocket.

The ACS also says whole-body MRI is not a substitute for regular checkups, recommended cancer screenings or medical care for symptoms.

The bottom line

A full-body MRI can sometimes find a real problem early. That is why a case like the recent brain tumor discovery drew attention.

But the FDA and major medical groups say there is still no proof that routine whole-body screening helps most healthy people more than it harms them. For now, the scan remains a choice that can bring both the possibility of early detection and the chance of unnecessary worry, extra testing and expense.

Share

Topics

Kevin Morgan

Kevin Morgan is a senior food and dining writer for Times Media Service, based in Los Angeles, California. Morgan covers food and dining, along with sports and health, bringing an evidence-based, community-focused approach to health reporting. Morgan holds a master's degree in sport administration and grew up in Canton, Ohio.

Write to Kevin