WASHINGTON, Oct. 21 (DC Times Online) — U.S. District Judge Ana Reyes withdrew a demand on Oct. 19 that the Justice Department identify the lawyers behind a court filing in a dispute over plans for Washington’s East Potomac Golf Links. The decision followed a courtroom confrontation with Associate Attorney General Stanley Woodward Jr. and a public attack by President Donald Trump.
The demand concerned who was responsible for a government brief. It was separate from the administration’s effort to remove Reyes from the case, which she had rejected.
“I’m going to withdraw request that DOJ refile yesterday’s brief with identification of who signed it,” Reyes said in court. “We’ve all got better things to spend our time on.”
What is the underlying lawsuit about?
The dispute concerns proposed renovation work at East Potomac Golf Links, a public course in Washington, D.C. A preservationist group and individual golfers brought the lawsuit, The Hill reported. The proposed changes affect those plaintiffs and people who use the course.
The lawsuit was first filed in February 2026, according to Yahoo News. The Justice Department represents the administration, while the Interior Department and National Park Service are involved in the course and proposed work.
Federal officials removed 430 trees on Oct. 10, USA TODAY reported. Yahoo News accounts described the number as roughly 430 or nearly 500. USA TODAY also reported that Reyes temporarily halted work after the removal.
Reyes held an emergency hearing on Oct. 12 in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, according to Yahoo News.
Trump has defended the renovation. In his Oct. 19 Truth Social post, he said the Interior Department wanted to turn what he called a “terrible and very unsafe golf course” into a “great, safe, and prestigious golf course.” He asserted that the department had “an absolute right to do so.”
Why did the government want a different judge?
The Justice Department sought Reyes’s disqualification on the Friday before the Oct. 19 hearing, The Hill reported. Disqualification, also called recusal, means a judge steps aside from a case.
In its motion, the department accused Reyes of a “pattern of animus against the Trump administration” and an “unorthodox and regrettable show of judicial impropriety.” Those were the government’s allegations about her conduct.
Reyes, who was appointed by former President Joe Biden, denied the request on the Sunday before the hearing, according to The Hill.
“It is easy to weaponize selective quotations to bring a baseless recusal motion. But it is much harder to meet the demanding legal standard against a full record,” she wrote in her opinion. “By any objective measure, the Government fails to meet the standard for recusal.”
Addressing the circumstances that prompted the court’s intervention, she wrote: “The Government created an emergent situation. The Court responded.”
What was the confrontation over the filing?
Woodward, the Justice Department’s No. 3 official, alone signed a separate government filing submitted that Sunday, Politico reported. Reyes wanted the department to identify the other lawyers behind it.
During the Oct. 19 hearing, she pressed for signatures. “I’m ordering you all to come to the podium and sign it. I’m giving them a direct order,” Reyes said, according to Lawfare’s Roger Parloff, whose hearing account was quoted by Raw Story.
Reyes told Woodward, “I don’t care what you think,” Politico reported. In another exchange reported by Politico’s Kyle Cheney, she said: “We can do this all day…I have nothing planned for this evening.”
Before dropping the demand, Reyes set a 3 p.m. deadline, extended it to noon Tuesday and offered to accept the lawyers’ names rather than their signatures, Yahoo News reported.
She ultimately announced, “Late breaking news,” before withdrawing the request. The Justice Department lawyers involved in the brief were the subjects of that withdrawn demand.
What did Trump say, and what did officials tell the court?
Before the Oct. 19 hearing, Trump attacked Reyes on Truth Social: “The judge on the case is a crazed lunatic whose courthouse tapes will reveal, may be insane?”
He also claimed that the judge had blocked the tapes from use and that a golfer bringing the lawsuit had “zero standing.” Standing is the legal requirement that a person have a sufficient stake in a dispute to bring a case; Trump’s statement was his position on the lawsuit.
“Work is scheduled to begin IMMEDIATELY!” Trump wrote.
At the hearing, however, Interior Department deputy chief of staff Greg Wischer and acting National Park Service director Jessica Bowron testified that plans for the course had not been finalized. USA TODAY identified both officials as witnesses questioned by Reyes.
Reyes also discussed her family’s response to reports of threats, saying relatives were “freaking out.” In another courtroom remark, she said: “I won’t ask if you think I’m crazy, lunatic, or insane.”
