LUBBOCK, Texas, Aug. 15 (Our Texas Times) — A federal judge in Texas has blocked enforcement of parts of the National Firearms Act against the plaintiffs in a lawsuit and certain people, businesses and government entities tied to them. The ruling has allowed gun-rights groups to begin testing what they describe as a major change in how suppressors and some other regulated firearms can be transferred.
The order is not a nationwide injunction. Its reach is limited to the parties covered by Judge James Wesley Hendrix’s order, including state agencies and political subdivisions in 15 states that joined the case. The full list of covered people and entities was not identified in the available reports.
The Justice Department did not ask for an emergency stay or appeal during the seven-day period Hendrix set after issuing his Aug. 5 order. The department could still pursue an appeal, and the available reports do not establish whether it has filed one since the order took effect Aug. 13.
What did the judge strike down?
The case challenged National Firearms Act requirements involving suppressors, short-barreled rifles, short-barreled shotguns and certain other firearms. A suppressor, sometimes called a silencer, is a device designed to reduce the sound of a gunshot. Short-barreled rifles and shotguns are firearms with barrels below the lengths specified in federal law.
The 1934 law required owners to register covered firearms and imposed a $200 tax on making or transferring them. Congress and President Donald Trump later eliminated that tax through legislation identified in the reports as the One Big Beautiful Bill Act.
Hendrix ruled that the challenged NFA provisions could no longer be supported by Congress’ taxing power after the tax was eliminated. In his opinion, he wrote:
“The challenged NFA provisions are unconstitutional.”
He also said:
“Efforts to render the NFA constitutional must come from Congress, not this Court.”
The ruling blocks federal officials from enforcing the challenged registration and related requirements against the parties covered by the order. It does not erase all federal firearms rules. Federal background checks remain required under the descriptions of the ruling provided by the sources.
What happened in Texas after the order?
Gun Owners of America said two members completed suppressor purchases just after midnight Aug. 13 at Silencer Shop in Leander without first completing NFA registration. The purchasers were identified as Brandon Herrera and Texas state Rep. Wes Virdell, R-Brady.
GOA described the transactions as the first lawful transfers without NFA registration since the law was enacted in 1934. That historical claim was not independently established in the available records.
Aidan Johnston, GOA’s federal affairs director, said the transactions showed the group’s members were putting the ruling into practice. Andrew Clyde, R-Ga., called the ruling “a monumental day for the country and a monumental day for the Second Amendment.”
The transactions do not establish that every gun owner in Texas, or elsewhere, may immediately buy a suppressor without registration. The order’s specific coverage depends on its language concerning the plaintiffs and associated parties, including members and future customers, and officials have not publicly provided a complete list of who is covered.
Why did the Justice Department not immediately challenge it?
The Justice Department said it was assessing the ruling’s impact and that it respects Americans’ Second Amendment rights. It did not seek emergency relief before Hendrix’s seven-day deadline expired.
That procedural decision allowed the order to take effect, but it did not necessarily end the case. The available reports differ about the remaining time for a regular appeal, so the controlling appellate docket would be needed to establish the exact deadline and whether an appeal has been filed.
What are the arguments on each side?
Gun-rights organizations, including GOA, the Firearms Policy Coalition and the Second Amendment Foundation, have portrayed the decision as a significant Second Amendment victory. GOA’s Erich Pratt said the group’s members were putting the ruling “into action” and argued that federal registration of constitutionally protected arms should end.
Gun-safety organization Giffords criticized the Justice Department’s decision not to seek an immediate appeal. Emma Brown of Giffords called it “a failure to defend public safety.”
The legal dispute centers on whether Congress may continue enforcing the NFA’s registration and related requirements after removing the tax that supported the law’s original constitutional rationale. Hendrix concluded that the challenged provisions were unconstitutional. The Justice Department’s next steps, and any review by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, could determine whether that conclusion remains in effect.
