Skip to content

ExplainerCrime and JusticeUnited States3 min read

Federal judge again blocks Trump mail-ballot rules as midterm election approaches

A federal judge has temporarily blocked the U.S. Postal Service from enforcing new mail-ballot requirements tied to a Trump executive order.

Share

Topics

WASHINGTON, Aug. 28 (Nationwide Times) — A federal judge has temporarily blocked the U.S. Postal Service from enforcing new mail-ballot requirements tied to President Donald Trump’s executive order, keeping the restrictions on hold nationwide for at least 14 days.

U.S. District Judge Indira Talwani issued the temporary restraining order after the Postal Service released a final rule on Aug. 21. The case is being litigated in several federal courts, including in Washington, D.C., and could return to the Supreme Court.

The order does not decide whether Trump’s executive order is lawful. It pauses the Postal Service’s implementation while the court considers whether to issue a longer-lasting injunction. Talwani scheduled a hearing for Sept. 3.

What would the Postal Service rules require?

The rules would require states to provide the Postal Service with lists of voters eligible to receive mail ballots. They also would require the use of a specific envelope format that includes a reviewed, unique barcode.

Trump’s March executive order sought to create a federal voter list and expand the Postal Service’s role in election operations. Democratic-led states, voting-rights organizations and the Democratic Party have challenged the order in separate lawsuits.

The challengers argue that the administration cannot impose these election requirements through the executive branch and the Postal Service. The administration is defending the policy in court.

Why did Talwani issue another order?

Talwani previously issued orders blocking the policy, including a nationwide injunction on Aug. 11. After the Supreme Court issued a procedural order on Aug. 24, Talwani lifted an earlier preliminary injunction while reconsidering the case.

The Postal Service’s final rule then restarted the legal challenge. Talwani’s latest order temporarily restored a nationwide block on implementation.

Talwani wrote that states would face a demanding timetable if they had to change their election systems before the midterms. “Plaintiff states have neither time nor funds to design new mail ballots, seek approval of the new designs, order production of mail ballots, update their own election management systems, train election officials to use the USPS portal and upload citizen data to the portal, all before the midterms,” she wrote.

What did the Supreme Court decide?

The Supreme Court’s Aug. 24 order was procedural. It paused or vacated an earlier Talwani injunction but did not rule on whether Trump’s executive order violates federal law.

The justices wrote that the decision on the application did not mean that any government action taken to implement the order would necessarily be lawful. “On that score, time will tell,” the unsigned order said.

That leaves the core legal dispute unresolved. The administration or the challengers may ask an appeals court to intervene, and the case could again reach the Supreme Court.

How does Washington, D.C., fit into the case?

A separate lawsuit is pending in federal court in Washington, D.C. In that case, U.S. District Judge Emmet Sullivan issued a nationwide order on July 1 blocking the Postal Service from implementing the plan. Sullivan said the proposal conflicted with a 2020 settlement involving the agency.

Another D.C. federal judge, Carl J. Nichols, declined in May to immediately block Trump’s executive order, saying the request was premature because the Postal Service had not yet issued its rule.

The overlapping lawsuits have produced several orders from different courts. The latest nationwide pause came from Talwani, who sits on the U.S. District Court in Boston, while the D.C. cases remain part of the broader legal fight over federal control of mail voting.

Share

Topics

Gary Smith

A lifelong Kingman resident, Gary Smith is the senior Kingman reporter for Times Media Service. Smith covers local news in Kingman, including local politics and government, schools, public safety, development and community life, from culture to the city's Route 66 heritage. Smith holds a master's degree in journalism and media studies.

Write to Gary