Skip to content

ExplainerBusiness and FinanceUnited States3 min read

Cato analysis puts 10-year cost of DSA platform at up to $212 trillion

A Cato Institute analysis estimates DSA proposals would require $71 trillion to $212 trillion in new federal spending over 10 years.

Share

Topics

WASHINGTON, Sept. 19 (DC Times Online) — A Washington-based Cato Institute analysis estimates that nine major proposals linked to the Democratic Socialists of America platform would require between $71 trillion and $212 trillion in additional federal spending over 10 years.

The estimate covers proposals that include universal health care, a federal jobs guarantee, reparations, housing, infrastructure and green-energy investment, expanded retirement benefits, paid family leave and no-cost college. The analysis was written by Adam N. Michel, Cato’s director of tax policy studies.

The figures are estimates from a think tank, not an official score from the Congressional Budget Office or another federal agency. Cato’s analysis also does not settle how the proposals would affect individual workers, customers, investors or communities. Their effects would depend on how Congress designed the programs and paid for them.

What is included in the estimate?

The largest item identified by Cato is a Medicare-for-All-style health care system. Cato estimates that such proposals would increase federal spending by $40 trillion to $75 trillion over 10 years. Other proposals in the nine-part estimate include a federal jobs guarantee, housing programs, infrastructure and climate-related investment, and broader public benefits.

The analysis treats these policies as additional federal spending. Michel said in a Cato podcast that the federal government currently spends about $7 trillion a year, or roughly $95 trillion over the next decade, before adding the proposals.

Cato estimates that the additional spending would equal about 18% to 53% of gross domestic product over the 10-year period. Gross domestic product, or GDP, is the total value of goods and services produced in the U.S. economy.

How might the government pay for it?

Cato says the agenda would require roughly doubling federal revenue at the low end of its estimate and quadrupling it at the high end. That would be in addition to raising money to cover the Congressional Budget Office’s cited projection of a $24 trillion federal deficit over the same 10-year period.

The DSA platform, as described in Cato’s analysis, says the cost would be directed to “the richest individuals and corporations.” The analysis does not establish that those taxpayers alone could generate enough revenue to cover the full range of projected spending.

For businesses and investors, the key issue would be the source of the new revenue and the effect of higher federal spending on taxes, wages, demand and borrowing. For workers and customers, the results would vary by program: Expanded benefits could reduce some household costs, while higher taxes or changes to employer-provided benefits could create costs elsewhere. Cato’s estimate itself does not provide a forecast for each group’s financial outcome.

What the estimate does — and does not — show

Michel said the proposals would add up to “somewhere between 70 and $212 trillion over 10 years of additional federal spending.” Cato’s published range is generally presented as $71 trillion to $212 trillion.

The estimate is a policy analysis rather than a government budget score, audited financial statement or regulatory finding. The supplied analysis does not include a full table of calculations for all nine proposals, and no response from DSA, the CBO or an independent budget analyst is included with the estimate.

That matters because the cost of broad programs depends on choices about eligibility, benefits, taxes, timing and whether existing federal or state programs are replaced. Different assumptions can produce substantially different totals.

The analysis therefore offers a large range for the possible federal spending associated with the DSA agenda, rather than a confirmed price tag for legislation that Congress has enacted. It also does not show that any of the proposals have been completed or funded.

Share

Topics

Joel Patterson

Joel Patterson is a senior business and finance analyst for Times Media Service, based in the Washington bureau. Patterson covers markets, companies, personal finance and economic policy, along with transportation and its financial and economic impacts. Patterson holds a master's degree in finance and grew up in Newcastle upon Tyne, England.

Write to Joel